California is finally adopting phonics, fulfilling a grandmother’s dream

Welcome to CalMatters, the only nonprofit newsroom devoted solely to covering statewide issues that affect all Californians. Sign up for

WeeklyMatters

for a Saturday morning digest of the latest news and commentary from the Golden State.

This story is part of

California Voices,

a commentary forum aiming to broaden our understanding of the state and spotlight Californians directly impacted by policy or its absence. Learn more

here

.

Marion Joseph

died in 2022 and therefore cannot celebrate what at long last is happening in California to improve children’s abysmal levels of reading comprehension.

Joseph, a renowned expert on reading instruction, came out of retirement in the 1980s to wage a personal crusade for the adoption of

phonics

, doing battle with educators who stubbornly supported a rival system called “

whole language

” that was failing to raise reading scores.

Phonics stresses fundamental instruction in the letters and letter combinations that make up sounds, thus allowing children to “sound out” words and later whole sentences and passages. The whole language approach assumes that reading is a naturally learned skill, much like speaking, and that exposing children to reading material will allow it to emerge.

Having realized that her own grandson, then a first-grader, was having difficulty with reading, Joseph began pestering the state’s politicians to adopt phonics, persuading then-Gov. Pete Wilson in the 1990s to appoint her to a commission on reading instruction and then the state Board of Education, platforms from which she could pursue her mission.

However, she achieved only modest success in what were dubbed “

reading wars

,” and after she left the school board the whole language approach re-emerged as dominant.

Reading scores on state and national academic tests continued to languish, with

fewer than half of fourth-graders reading

at an acceptable level.

School districts that had voluntarily adopted phonics demonstrated remarkable gains. They recognized that the ability to read is fundamental to succeeding in other academic skills, such as mathematics.

Finally substantial numbers of legislators decided to intervene, and a

pro-phonics contingent

began pushing measures that would compel school districts to adopt what has been dubbed the “science of reading,” backed by a phalanx of education reformers.

Δ

Gov. Gavin Newsom, who has

struggled with dyslexia

, a disorder affecting his ability to read, supported the efforts and included $200 million in the 2025-26 state budget to train teachers in phonics.

Meanwhile

Assembly Bill 1454

is moving quickly through the legislative process. Sponsored by pro-phonics legislators including Assembly Speaker

Robert Rivas

, it would require the state Board of Education to adopt phonics-based instructional materials and include phonics in reading teacher credential programs.

Read Next

California politicians agree on school money, but poor test scores need attention

The pro-phonics moves are drawing praise from EdVoice and dozens of other educational reform groups.

“When a child learns to read, they don’t just decode letters on a page, they begin to dream bigger, think more critically, and imagine a future beyond what they can see. Today’s committee approval brings us one step closer to all California children reading at grade level,” said Marshall Tuck, CEO of Ed Voice, after the bill cleared the Senate Education Committee last week.

Assemblymember

Blanca Rubio

, a West Covina Democrat who has become the Legislature’s top phonics advocate, said, “After months of hard work and collaboration, we are making steady progress toward delivering on our promise to teach all California children to read. The support we saw today in the Senate Education Committee moves us closer to ensuring that no child falls through the cracks because they weren’t taught to read using scientifically proven reading methods. The continued bipartisan support on this bill tells us that California is ready and motivated to lead on literacy.”

The actions fall a bit short of

requiring local school districts to adopt phonics

, but they go a long way toward achieving Marion Joseph’s goal.

Read More

The ‘science of reading’ won’t be required in California schools, at least for now

Too many California kids can’t read. Will phonics help?

Read more from CalMatters

Text

Get breaking news on your phone.

Download

Keep up with the latest via our app.

Sign up

Receive free updates in your inbox.

Safeguard independent news for California’s future

For 10 years, CalMatters has informed millions of Californians and kept our government and special interests in check.

• We report what’s happening.
• We ask the hard questions.
• We make our government transparent to Californians.

Right now, every donation is matched dollar-for-dollar. Please make today the day you support CalMatters.

Without independent, relentless reporting, accountability slips:

• People lose visibility into decisions that shape their future.
• Misinformation and special interests gain more ground.
• Public trust erodes.

Don’t let that happen. Give today to safeguard independent and fearless CalMatters journalism.

Give today, because the news can’t wait.