Federal immigration crackdown threatens California’s historic housing reforms

Welcome to CalMatters, the only nonprofit newsroom devoted solely to covering statewide issues that affect all Californians. Sign up for

WeeklyMatters

for a Saturday morning digest of the latest news and commentary from the Golden State.

This story is part of

California Voices,

a commentary forum aiming to broaden our understanding of the state and spotlight Californians directly impacted by policy or its absence. Learn more

here

.

Guest Commentary written by

Nils Gilman

Nils Gilman is the chief operating officer and executive vice president of the Berggruen Institute.

California has finally made real progress on one of its most stubborn problems: the housing crisis. After decades of paralysis, the

state has begun to unwind the bureaucratic thicket

that made it almost impossible to build new homes in cities. This should be a moment for cautious optimism.

Yet a new and very different problem looms — one that threatens to undermine these hard-won reforms before a single unit is built: a growing national effort to crack down on the

very workers California needs to build its future

.

This summer, Gov. Gavin Newsom

pushed through a pair of bills

—

Assembly Bill 130

and

Senate Bill 131

— that amount to the most significant overhaul of California’s development rules in more than 50 years. In particular, the reforms are massively curtailing the California Environmental Quality Act, which for decades has allowed opponents to block urban housing with endless lawsuits and reviews.

Urban infill projects near transit are now largely exempt from CEQA litigation. Developers are, for the first time in a generation, preparing to build at scale.

But just as California removes the red tape, it may find itself caught in another bind: a lack of construction workers. And this time, the cause isn’t homegrown.

More than 40%

of California’s construction workforce is foreign-born, according to the National Association of Homebuilders. That includes more than half a million immigrants, many of them undocumented, who work as framers, drywallers, roofers and laborers.

These are physically demanding jobs, often shunned by native-born workers. Without them, the math of housing development simply doesn’t work.

Δ

Yet the national political winds are blowing in the opposite direction. The Trump-aligned right has completely changed the conversation about

immigration

. Their focus is on deporting not just criminals, but

all

undocumented migrants. Mass deportation, as recently as last year

considered a fringe idea

, is now the openly stated

policy objective

.

Read Next

Worksite immigration raids are supposed to free up jobs for citizens. Here’s what really happens

The implications for industries that rely heavily on immigrants are as dire as they are obvious. Heightened enforcement, even without sweeping raids, creates fear and uncertainty. Some workers leave preemptively.

Others move into the shadows

.

The result? Just as building permits get faster, the labor force that builds will get scarcer. Construction firms already report difficulty assembling full crews. Wages are rising. Projects are being delayed — not by paperwork, but by

a shortage of hands

.

If this trend continues, California risks an awkward outcome: a flood of new housing approvals but not enough workers to actually build them. The “abundance agenda” could turn into a shelf full of blueprints.

In the worst case, we end up with a hollow boom — developments greenlit but never started, or started but never finished.

As construction lags, pressure will mount on Sacramento to push back against federal immigration policy.

California has clashed with Washington

before — on climate, guns, and abortion. Housing could be next. Newsom, perhaps

eyeing national office

, may argue that federal immigration enforcement is sabotaging state-led economic reform.

This will be a high-stakes confrontation. The federal government controls immigration. California controls land use. The two are now on a collision course.

The deeper irony is hard to miss. For years, the consensus was that California’s housing problems were self-inflicted — caused by too much regulation and not enough political courage. Now that the state is finally addressing those issues, it’s being undermined by a different kind of politics: a national campaign against the very people who build homes.

If California wants to realize its new housing vision, it will need not just faster permits but also enough skilled workers to turn blueprints into homes. That means protecting the workforce it has — even when doing so puts it at odds with Washington.

Otherwise, we will be left with the worst of both worlds: new rules, no results and a housing crisis that continues to degrade the quality of life for far too many Californians.

Read More

California lawmakers finally achieve ‘holy grail’ reform of state’s key environmental law

Federal DEI, ‘wokeness’ restrictions put California homeless providers in a bind

Read more from CalMatters

Text

Get breaking news on your phone.

Download

Keep up with the latest via our app.

Sign up

Receive free updates in your inbox.

Safeguard independent news for California’s future

For 10 years, CalMatters has informed millions of Californians and kept our government and special interests in check.

• We report what’s happening.
• We ask the hard questions.
• We make our government transparent to Californians.

Right now, every donation is matched dollar-for-dollar. Please make today the day you support CalMatters.

Without independent, relentless reporting, accountability slips:

• People lose visibility into decisions that shape their future.
• Misinformation and special interests gain more ground.
• Public trust erodes.

Don’t let that happen. Give today to safeguard independent and fearless CalMatters journalism.

Give today, because the news can’t wait.