In conclusion
During his first in-person town hall since Trump’s megabill was signed into law, Republican Representative Doug LaMalfa fielded a hostile crowd’s questions and comments filled with profanity while mainly defending his vote for Trump’s megabill.
Greetings from CalMatters, the only nonprofit news organization dedicated exclusively to reporting on topics that impact all Californians. To get the most recent information and analysis on the most significant topics in the Golden State, sign up for WhatMatters.
At a town hall in Chico early Monday, Republican Representative Doug LaMalfa, who represents a large portion of the rural north of California, had just started his prepared remarks when he was overwhelmed by jeers and boos.
For almost ninety minutes, the boisterous interruptions persisted.
His vote for President Donald Trump’s budget bill, which cuts more than $1.1 trillion in federal spending for Medicaid, Medicare, and plans under the Affordable Care Act over the next ten years, was met with a barrage of profanity from the more than 650 people gathered at the local Elks Lodge. LaMalfa was chastised by the crowd for endorsing legislation that they claimed would destroy rural hospitals and harm impoverished families and vulnerable individuals with disabilities.
However, LaMalfa asserted that the proposal exclusively targets waste, fraud, and abuse—a typical and deceptive argument used by House Republicans nationwide to support the legislation—and does not make any cuts to the people who participate in California’s Medicaid program, known as Medi-Cal.
That is untrue! When LaMalfa trotted out this refrain, a number of spectators yelled, to a chorus of jeers. No shame!
Do you obtain things this way? By shouting? LaMalfa retaliated.
At his first in-person forum in over eight years, LaMalfa mainly defended his record, as well as that of his party and the president, in Chico, a Democratic college town that is one of the few blue spots in his congressional district, which leans Republican.
As they return to their home districts for the six-week August recess, congressional Republicans across have encountered angry audiences as they attempt to persuade people to support the president’s new domestic policy initiative, which surveys indicate is largely unpopular.
The Democratic Party is hoping that the outpouring of resentment at GOP town halls in blue communities like Chico will translate into a victory in the midterm elections.Similar to LaMalfa’s town hall, one in Lincoln, Nebraska, had constituents lining up around the block to enter the building and then booing loudly once inside.
Additionally, LaMalfa’s town hall coincides with California Democrats and Governor Gavin Newsom’s mad rush to redraw the state’s congressional districts in an attempt to counter Trump’s strategy of keeping control of the U.S. House by wringing more Republican seats out of red areas like Florida and Texas. LaMalfa and four other Republicans may be drawn into significantly bluer districts by the proposed California maps, which are anticipated to be released this week, according to people who have seen the designs but are not permitted to talk publicly.
A number of people turned around and departed because the large common room was so crowded. Inside, constituents lined up to comment and ask questions, creating two disorderly lines that ran along both sides of the room. Staff distributed red and green placards for guests to indicate their opinions in an attempt to curb audience outbursts, but this did little to calm the gathering.
To be the first person in line to ask LaMalfa if he supported the megabill, Mathew Hilliard, a youth mental health counselor and social worker from Mount Shasta, drove more than 2.5 hours and waited outside for an additional hour. He expressed to the congressman his deep fear that rural hospitals in Siskiyou County and throughout the district might have to close as a result of Medi-Cal’s defunding.
According to Hilliard, these facilities are essential for our working-class and disabled citizens. How could you be in favor of a bill that would destroy our already vulnerable infrastructure?
Responding from his position on a barstool onstage, LaMalfa made the deceptive Republican assertion that the law will instead exclude those he believes should not be eligible for the program, including able-bodied working individuals without dependents and those who are illegally in the country.
Ask Gavin Newsom why he believes that the Medi-Cal program will suffer because $12.5 billion will go to people who aren’t even state residents.
This year, a projected budget shortage forced Newsom to limit the expansion of Medi-Cal membership to those in the nation without legal status.
According to estimates from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, Trump’s legislation will result in over 10 million people—including over 3.4 million Californians—losing health care coverage by 2034.
While the focus of the lively event was health care, other topics covered included the Israel-Gaza war and Congress’s handling of the Jeffrey Epstein files. Several commenters bemoaned White House overreach as Trump pushed the limits of presidential power. Many expressed their rage at immigration officials’ indiscriminate raids on U.S. citizens and legal residents, accusing LaMalfa of facilitating a slide into fascism.
Later, LaMalfa acknowledged that U.S. citizens shouldn’t be detained by immigration officials and declared his support for a legalization option for illegal workers in vital sectors like agriculture and services. However, he later contradicted himself, saying that officials should not be discouraged from conducting a broad search, as they have done in recent raids at Home Depot parking lots in Sacramento and Los Angeles, and then sorting out those who were unlawfully held. This is because officials are afraid of mistakenly detaining a citizen or permanent resident.
Since fewer government figures are prepared to prostrate themselves in the current hyperpartisan climate, the in-person, open mic town hall has progressively become a thing of the past in the era of social media. Following a flood of unfavorable headlines from viral town hall encounters earlier this year, especially with their own GOP supporters, House Republicans even discouraged their members from having in-person forums.
The crowd was informed by LaMalfa’s staff that if they stopped interrupting, they could get through more questions and remarks. Even after a few speakers pleaded with the audience to speak up, there was little desire for polite conversation.
Ryan Rogoski, a Chico Navy veteran, informed LaMalfa that he had travel three hours round-trip to San Rafael to visit a therapist for PTSD because there aren’t enough mental health professionals in the area. The congressman acknowledged that this was absurd and unacceptable. However, when Rogoski pleaded with LaMalfa to address the provider shortage, LaMalfa blamed it on a few bad apples in the local Chico VA’s leadership who, he claimed, misused the monies that were already there.
You’re spending a lot of money on the Pentagon! Before hurriedly leaving the premises in tears, Rogoski yelled. Later, using an obscenity to highlight his annoyance, he informed CalMatters that LaMalfa’s response was blatantly untrue.
According to Rogoski, it has nothing to do with caring for veterans or our particular difficulties.
Like fellow California Representative Kevin Kiley, who recently sponsored a bill to outlaw mid-decade redistricting, some residents urged LaMalfa to condemn all of the redistricting initiatives this year.
However, LaMalfa noted that since voters established an independent redistricting committee about 20 years ago, California’s attempt was particularly despicable.
In order to make it independent, perhaps the people in Texas and other states may establish their own commissions, LaMalfa stated in an interview. “That’s really ugly,” he continued. It doesn’t increase your trust in the political system.
READ NEXT
Texas Democrats embrace Newsom s redistricting rebuttal as California draws new map
This candidate for California governor has a potential conflict of interest in her own home
CalMatters has further information.
Text
Receive breaking news on your mobile device.
Get it here
Use our app to stay up to date.
Register
Get free updates delivered straight to your inbox.
Nonpartisan, independent California news for all
CalMatters is your impartial, nonprofit news source.
Our goal remains crucial, and our journalists are here to empower you.
-
We are independent and nonpartisan.
Our trustworthy journalism is free from partisan politics, free from corporate influence and actually free for all Californians. -
We are focused on California issues.
From the environment to homelessness, economy and more, we publish the unfettered truth to keep you informed. -
We hold people in power accountable.
We probe and reveal the actions and inactions of powerful people and institutions, and the consequences that follow.
However, without the help of readers like you, we are unable to continue.
Give what you can now, please. Every gift makes a difference.
