In summary
After his staffer’s baby was woken up by a loud ad on a streaming service, a California senator took action to force streamers to turn down the volume on commercials. The entertainment industry is fighting it.
Welcome to CalMatters, the only nonprofit newsroom devoted solely to covering issues that affect all Californians. Sign up for
WhatMatters
to receive the latest news and commentary on the most important issues in the Golden State.
Ever been streaming a show or a movie and been jolted out of your entertainment reverie by an ad so loud it felt like it rattled the windows?
If California’s lawmakers have their way, those blaring commercials on streaming platforms might soon have the volume turned down.
A bill sailing through the Legislature with bipartisan support would prohibit online streaming services like Netflix and Hulu from cranking up the volume during commercials. The proposal would make the platforms comply with the same standards as a 15-year-old federal law that limits how loud traditional television and cable broadcasters can make their advertisements.
Senate Bill 576
hasn’t been a very tough sell for its author, Democratic Sen.
Tom Umberg
of Santa Ana, despite opposition from California’s influential entertainment industry.
“This is the most popular bill I’ve introduced this year,” Umberg said in an interview with CalMatters.
Case in point: Every senator who was present that day voted for the bill when Umberg brought it to the Senate floor in late May. Umberg appealed to their annoyance.
“I’m guessing that all of you have been annoyed when you’re … streaming television, and a commercial comes on and it is exponentially louder than the other shows,” Umberg
told his colleagues
.
He glanced around the chamber. “You see heads nodding aye.”
President Barack Obama signed the Commercial Advertisement Loudness Mitigation (CALM) Act in 2010, which gave the Federal Communications Commission authority to issue rules ensuring that the average volume of TV commercials does not exceed the volume of the programming they accompany, according to the bill’s analysis. It notes that streaming services were still nascent at the time. Members of Congress have since tried to add streaming platforms to the law, but two 2023 federal bills didn’t get hearings.
Umberg’s bill aims to make streaming services in California follow the same rules despite Congress not yet taking action.
But would it be legal for California to do so?
UC Berkeley Law Professor Tejas Narechania told CalMatters that federal courts have ruled “that the California Legislature could enact consumer protections aimed at California residents, even if they affected out-of-state content providers.”
Narechania cited a 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruling in favor of a California deaf-rights organization that sued CNN for violating state law by failing to put closed captioning on videos it had on its website.
Umberg: Don’t wake the baby!
While a significant amount of legislation comes to lawmakers through lobbyists pitching their proposals, this one came to Umberg from a baby. Well, the baby’s parents anyway.
He said his legislative director, Zach Keller, has an infant daughter named Samantha Rose. The baby had finally settled down to sleep and her parents, in turn, settled down to relax and watch a show when an ad came on so loud it woke the baby.
“Her father, at the behest of the baby’s mother, brought a bill idea to me,” Umberg said. “I thought, ‘That’s a good bill idea,’ so we introduced it.”
The plight of parents with sleeping babies hasn’t been enough to ward off opposition to the bill from California’s entertainment industry, including the Motion Picture Association of America. It has donated at least $204,000 to lawmakers since 2015, according to the
CalMatters Digital Democracy database
.
Learn more about legislators mentioned in this story.
Thomas Umberg
Democrat, State Senate, District 34 (Santa Ana)
Opponents, including the Streaming Innovation Alliance, argue that the proposal would be difficult for streaming services to implement.
Streaming service ads don’t work the same way as commercials at cable and television networks, Melissa Patack, a representative for the Motion Picture Association,
told the Assembly’s Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee
last month.
“When you choose a program on your streaming service, you’re actually calling up a digital file and advertising is paired up with that in real time,” she said. “The streaming platform may not be able to control the loudness of a particular ad.”
Patack added
that the streaming industry has done “a significant amount of work” already to “address loudness issues and develop best practices to match the loudness of ads with programming.”
Umberg isn’t buying it.
“I have a great deal of faith in the entertainment industry, in the technology that they both currently use and are developing, that if they can make ads louder, they can make them less loud,” he said.
Umberg’s bill now moves to the Assembly floor where Umberg is again likely to appeal to lawmakers’ desire for streamers not to wake up more babies such as Samantha Rose
More from Digital Democracy
California lawmakers side with landlords to kill renter eviction relief
California doesn’t have enough court reporters. Their unions are fighting substitutes
California proposal would allow soft helmet pads in youth football leagues
Read more from CalMatters
Text
Get breaking news on your phone.
Download
Keep up with the latest via our app.
Sign up
Receive free updates in your inbox.
Safeguard independent news for California’s future
For 10 years, CalMatters has informed millions of Californians and kept our government and special interests in check.
- We report what’s happening.
- We ask the hard questions.
- We make our government transparent to Californians.
Right now, every donation is matched dollar-for-dollar. Please make today the day you support CalMatters.
Without independent, relentless reporting, accountability slips:
- People lose visibility into decisions that shape their future.
- Misinformation and special interests gain more ground.
- Public trust erodes.
Don’t let that happen. Give today to safeguard independent and fearless CalMatters journalism.
Give today, because the news can’t wait.
